Best period underwear: our comparison guide
Choosing your first period underwear often feels like a gamble: you don’t know what absorbency to aim for, which cut will really stay in place under jeans, or whether the €15 style is as good as the €39 one. As a result, many women buy a pair that isn’t absorbent enough, find it disappointing, and go back to disposable period products.
This guide is written by a brand that has been making period underwear since 2018. We therefore acknowledge our bias and prefer to say so upfront. In return, we give you verifiable figures: absorbency capacities expressed in milliliters and tampon equivalents, precise definitions of flow levels, and certification numbers. Enough to compare any brand, including ours.
The best period underwear is the pair whose absorbency matches your actual flow. It’s the only criterion that can make a purchase a failure. Everything else (cut, color, material) comes down to personal comfort.
- Light flow (at the beginning and end of your period): the equivalent of one regular tampon is enough. A thong or a lightweight pair of underwear.
- Medium flow (30 to 50 ml per cycle): aim for the equivalent of 2 tampons, or about 12 hours of protection.
- Heavy flow (over 50 ml): aim for 4 tampons’ worth. This is the style that helps you get a full night’s sleep.
- Very heavy flow: you need 150 ml, or 6 tampons. Few styles offer this much absorbency.
- Budget: expect to pay €90 to €200 for 3 to 5 pairs to cover a cycle without doing laundry every day, depending on the styles.
The 5 criteria that really matter
Most comparison guides list fifteen criteria. In reality, five are enough, and they don’t all carry the same weight.
| Criterion | Importance | What to look for |
|---|---|---|
| Absorbency | Decisive | Expressed in ml or tampon equivalents. If the brand doesn’t say, that’s a warning sign. |
| Size | Very high | Too large, and it leaks at the sides. Too tight, and it leaves marks. Go by your hip measurement, not your jeans size. |
| Cut | Medium | A matter of comfort and how it fits under clothing. No impact on effectiveness. |
| Material | Medium | Cotton for a natural feel, microfiber for a fine fit and quick drying. |
| Certifications | High | OEKO-TEX® STANDARD 100 with a certificate number, GOTS for organic cotton, and no PFAS. |
Swipe horizontally to view the table.
Flow: the only criterion that can really make a purchase fail
Menstrual flow can be measured. At Smoon, the thresholds used to design each style are as follows:
- Medium flow: blood loss of between 30 and 50 ml per cycle (2 to 3 tablespoons), requiring fewer than one period product every three hours.
- Heavy flow: blood loss of more than 50 ml per cycle (at least 3 tablespoons), requiring more than one period product every three hours.
This three-hour test is the easiest to do yourself. If you change your tampon or pad more often than every three hours on your heaviest days, your flow is heavy, and “medium flow” underwear will disappoint you.
Buying just one style for the entire cycle. Flow is not constant: it is heavy on days 1 and 2, then light. The best combination is a highly absorbent style for the beginning of your period, a medium-absorbency style for the following days, and possibly a string for the end.
Sizing: the second pitfall
Period underwear absorbs through its central panel, but it is leakproof because it fits snugly. A style that is too large creates gaps at the sides, and that is where almost all leaks mistakenly attributed to insufficient absorbency occur. Take your measurements rather than relying on your usual size: size charts vary widely from one brand to another.
Certifications: what to check
A label displayed without a number means nothing. An OEKO-TEX® STANDARD 100 certificate has a verifiable number. Smoon microfiber underwear is certified under number CQ 1285/1, and the very heavy flow style under number CQ 1285/2. For cotton styles, look for GOTS certification, which covers the cultivation of the fiber and not just the finished product, as well as the explicit “PFAS-free” label.
Comparison by flow: which pair for which need
Here is the Smoon range, ordered by increasing absorbency. The tampon equivalents are those used on each product page; a regular tampon absorbs about 5 ml.
| Style | Flow | Absorbency | Protection | Price |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| String Aphrodite | Light | 1 tampon | Beginning and end of period | 32 € |
| Ara, cotton | Medium | 2 tampons | Up to 8 hours | 25 € |
| Séléné, microfiber | Medium | 2 tampons | Up to 12 hours | 35 € |
| Boyshort Amphitrite | Medium | 2 tampons | Up to 12 hours | 35 € |
| Calliope, high-waisted shaping | Medium | 2 tampons | Up to 12 hours | 39 € |
| Aquilla, cotton | Heavy | 4 tampons | Day and night | 30 € |
| Artémis, microfiber | Heavy | 4 regular tampons or 2 super tampons | Up to 12 hours | 39 € |
| Héméra, detachable | Heavy | 4 tampons | Up to 12 hours | 44 € |
| Hécate | Very heavy | 150 ml, equivalent to 6 tampons | Day and night without changing | 45 € |
Swipe horizontally to view the table.
- For getting started: Séléné, the range’s best-selling and most versatile model.
- For nights and days 1 and 2: Artémis, which absorbs twice as much.
- For very heavy flows and nighttime: Hécate, the only model with a 150 ml capacity.
- For a cotton feel: Ara or Aquilla, made with GOTS-certified cotton and free from PFAS.
- For changing away from home: Héméra, with a detachable absorbent part.
How period underwear works
Period underwear is not underwear lined with a pad. L'absorption is built into the garment, in three layers stacked in the gusset.
- The wicking layer, in contact with the skin, lets the flow pass inward and stays dry. It’s what eliminates the feeling of dampness.
- The absorbent layer retains and neutralizes blood, preventing odors throughout wear.
- The waterproof layer, on the outside, prevents leaks onto clothing.
At Smoon, these three materials are assembled seamlessly, resulting in a thickness half that of the average and complete invisibility under fitted clothing. The technology was developed in Paris over two years with a textile engineer.
How long can you wear it
Between 8 and 12 hours, depending on the style and flow intensity, not according to a universal rule. A useful guideline: change your underwear when you feel uncomfortable, not at a set time. On your heaviest days, it's normal to change it once during the day, just as you would with disposable period protection.
How many pairs of period underwear do you need for one cycle
Three to five, depending on how long your period lasts and your laundry routine. Fewer than three means doing laundry every day. The most common combination is two high-absorbency pairs and two medium-absorbency pairs.
Which cut should you choose
The cut makes no difference to absorbency: for the same flow, boyshorts and thongs of the same model offer equal protection. However, it does affect comfort and how the underwear sits under clothing.
If discretion is your top priority, take a look at the seamless styles: the lack of stitching along the edges prevents visible lines under thin pants. For body shapes that need more room, the plus-size period underwear provides better support without squeezing.
Organic cotton or microfiber: which should you choose
This is the question we get asked most often, and the answer depends mainly on your skin and laundry routine.
| GOTS-certified cotton | Microfiber | |
|---|---|---|
| Feel | Soft, matte, like regular underwear | Second-skin feel, very thin |
| Breathability | Very breathable | Breathable |
| Discretion | Visible under very tight clothing | Invisible, twice as thin |
| Drying | Longer | Quick |
| Wear time | Up to 8 hours | Up to 12 hours |
| Starting price | 25 € | 35 € |
Swipe horizontally to view the table.
Smoon’s cotton styles (Ara for medium flow, Aquilla for heavy flow) are GOTS-certified, guaranteed PFAS-free, and have been validated for skin tolerance through a study. This is the most reassuring starting point for a first pair of period underwear. See the full range in the cotton period underwear collection.
Period underwear for teens: what’s different
Only two things distinguish period underwear for teens from adult styles: the size range, which starts at around age 10, and the cut, designed for hips that are still developing. LAbsorbency, however, follows the same rules.
The real challenge lies elsewhere: bodies change quickly, and underwear bought at age 11 often no longer fits at 13. The One Size style solves this problem, fitting ages 10 to 16 thanks to memory-shape yarn, with protection for up to 12 hours for a flow equivalent to 2 tampons.
For a first period, choose two styles rather than just one, including a boyshort. Many teenage girls prefer boyshorts at school because they offer more coverage and are easy to forget about during PE. Our article on first periods: what to expect answers the most frequently asked questions.
Compare menstrual underwear brands
The French market now has dozens of brands, including Fempo, Réjeanne, Elia, Sisters Republic, Marguette, Modibodi, and Moodz. Rather than ranking them for you, here’s the checklist we’d use ourselves to compare a brand we don’t know.
The 7 questions to ask before buying
- Is absorbency specified? In milliliters or tampon equivalents, for each product. A brand that is vague about this leaves you guessing.
- Is the certification number displayed? OEKO-TEX® STANDARD 100 without a verifiable number proves nothing.
- Does the materials list mention PFAS? Lack of information does not guarantee they are absent.
- Where is the product designed and manufactured? Design and manufacturing are two different things, and many brands only talk about the former.
- What is the return policy? Underwear needs to be tried on. Without the option to return or exchange it, all the risk is yours.
- Is the size guide based on measurements? Matching directly to clothing sizes is a shortcut that can lead to leaks.
- How many customer reviews, and on which platform? A high volume on a verified platform is more valuable than a perfect score based on ten reviews.
What Smoon brings to the table
Since we ask you to check out other brands, here are our own answers, all verifiable on our website:
- French brand founded in 2018 by Mathilde and Marine, with products developed in Paris alongside a textile engineer.
- The first period underwear brand to obtain B Corp certification, in 2023.
- OEKO-TEX® STANDARD 100 certification, numbers CQ 1285/1 and CQ 1285/2.
- Absorbency specified on every product page, from the thong at 1 tampon to Hécate at 150 ml.
- 60 days to try it, free exchanges, and free delivery on orders over €49 via Mondial Relay.
- Partnerships with the French Swimming Federation, the French Boxing Federation, Decathlon, and Kiprun.
- More than 800 customer reviews for the Séléné model alone.
The range also goes beyond underwear: period swimwear designed for swimming, period leggings and shorts, and postpartum lingerie. This is what sets us apart most clearly from brands focused on just one product.
How much does it cost, and when does it pay for itself?
A pair of period underwear costs between €25 and €45, depending on the model and material. L'The initial investment is therefore significant: between €90 and €200 for a set of three to five pairs.
The fairest comparison is over time. Well-cared-for underwear can be worn for several years, while disposable products need to be repurchased every month. The break-even point depends on your current usage and how many pairs you buy. We explain the calculation in our article on the cost of period products.
Two ways to lower the upfront cost are starter packs, which cost less than buying items individually, and, in some cases, reimbursement through your health insurance, which few people think to ask about.
Care: how to make it last
It’s care, more than the product’s initial quality, that determines how long period underwear lasts. Just follow four rules.
- Rinse with cold water immediately after wearing, without soap, until the water runs clear. L'hot water sets blood stains.
- Wash in cold water or at 30 °C, on a delicate machine cycle or by hand.
- No oily soap or fabric softener. They clog the absorbent membrane and irreversibly reduce its effectiveness. Do not use white vinegar: it can loosen the heat-bonding on the absorbent area. For stubborn odors or stains, use a little baking soda instead.
- Do not tumble dry. Air-dry only.
Our complete guide, how to care for your period underwear, covers special cases, including set-in stains.
Frequently asked questions
-
01What is the best period underwear?
Choose one with an absorbency level that matches your flow. For a medium flow, aim for the equivalent of 2 tampons; for a heavy flow, 4 tampons; for a very heavy flow, 150 ml, or 6 tampons. Underwear that isn’t absorbent enough will leak, regardless of the brand, while underwear that’s too absorbent will simply be thicker than necessary.
-
02How long can you wear period underwear?
Between 8 and 12 hours, depending on the model and flow intensity. Smoon’s microfiber models offer up to 12 hours of protection, while the cotton models offer up to 8 hours. On your heaviest days, plan to change during the day.
-
03How many pairs of period underwear do you need for one cycle?
Three to five. Fewer than three means doing laundry every day. The most practical mix is two highly absorbent styles for the first few days and two medium-absorbency styles for the rest.
-
04Which period underwear is best for a very heavy flow?
You need a style specifically designed for this, with an absorbent area that's wider and extends higher at the front and back. The Hécate underwear absorbs 150 ml, equivalent to 6 tampons, and is designed for the heaviest flows and overnight wear. Find the other styles in the range in the very heavy flow collection.
-
05Is period underwear really invisible under clothes?
It depends on the construction. Seamless styles, with the absorbency integrated without stitching along the edges, don't leave a visible line, even under fitted pants. Styles with visible hems show more. Smoon microfiber underwear is twice as thin as the market average.
-
06Organic cotton or microfiber: which fabric should you choose?
GOTS-certified cotton for a feel similar to regular underwear. Microfiber for a lightweight feel, invisibility under fitted clothes, quick drying, and longer wear time. Both offer equally good protection at the same absorbency level.
-
07At what age can a teenager wear period underwear?
From their first period. Teen sizes start at age 10. It's actually the easiest protection to start with, as it requires no internal insertion. The One Size style fits ages 10 to 16, so there's no need to buy a new pair with every change in body shape.
-
08How do you wash period underwear?
Rinse it in cold water without soap immediately after wearing, until the water runs clear. Then wash it in cold water or at 30°C, on a delicate cycle in the washing machine or by hand. Avoid greasy soap and fabric softener, which can clog the absorbent membrane, and never put the underwear in the dryer.








































